Key Takeaways
- The Alesis Melody 61 MK4 is listed at approximately MXN $1,599 (about USD $90) and targets first-time players with 61 full-sized keys, 300 built-in sounds, built-in speakers and bundled accessories.
- The Yamaha PSR-F52, Yamaha’s most budget-friendly 61-key model, typically costs more in local markets, but offers robust features and brand trust.
- The price difference reflects three factors: sound-engine fidelity and realism; key action and touch sensitivity; and build quality plus feature-set (connectivity, durability).
- For casual exploration, a model like the Melody 61 suffices. For sustained learning and technique development, investing in a stronger model like the PSR-F52 (or higher) delivers better value.
Story & Details
Comparing the Products
The Alesis Melody 61 MK4 is presented as a portable, beginner-friendly keyboard: 61 full-sized unweighted keys, 300 built-in voices and rhythms, record-and-play mode, USB-MIDI support and bundled accessories. (Source: Alesis product announcement)
The Yamaha PSR-F52 offers 61 full-sized keys, a wide voice-and-style library, auto-accompaniment and layer/split functions—but its keys are not touch-sensitive (velocity-responsive) in most reviews, limiting expressive dynamics. (Source: Yamaha PSR-F52 review)
Price, Value and Market Position
In Mexico the Alesis model appears around MXN $1,599 according to a marketplace listing. Meanwhile, Yamaha’s entry model in Europe is listed from about EUR €89 (~USD $95) but actual local pricing tends to be higher once shipping/taxes are included. Given this, the Yamaha product often carries a premium in real-world markets.
The higher cost can be attributed to:
- Sound engine and realism: More refined sampling and polyphony raise costs.
- Key action and touch sensitivity: Velocity-sensitive or weighted keys increase manufacturing complexity.
- Build materials, speakers, features: Better speakers, more durable casing, and growth-friendly connectivity raise cost.
Design, Materials and Intended Use
The Alesis model focuses on portability and convenience: lightweight design, basic key action (non-touch sensitive), built-in speakers, and a starter kit feel. Ideal for children or casual learners whose aim is to explore rather than master technique.
The Yamaha PSR-F52 is still entry-level but benefits from Yamaha’s reputation: full-sized keys, decent voice library, though lacking velocity sensitivity in the unit reviewed. Buyers investing in technique will likely find its limitations sooner than a more advanced model, but it offers a significant step up from toy-style keyboards.
Guidance from Expert Sources
Music gear buying guides emphasise that for beginner keyboards:
- Full-sized keys (standard width) matter for hand posture and transition to real piano.
- Touch sensitivity (velocity response) is important for technique and expressive playing.
- Built-in speakers plus headphone output enable flexible practice locations and quiet mode.
- Connectivity (USB, MIDI, pedal input) helps extend the instrument’s usefulness beyond the beginner phase.
A discussion in an online keyboard-enthusiast forum pointed out:
“You need to make sure that any keyboard you buy has, at minimum, 61 touch sensitive keys and support for a sustain pedal.” (translated from forum comment)
This highlights potential shortcomings of very low-cost models if the aim is serious learning.
Recommendation Based on Use Case
- Casual learner or young beginner: The Alesis Melody 61 MK4 offers a low-risk, low-cost way to get started—good for trying out if keyboard-playing is enjoyable.
- Learner planning to study and improve: The Yamaha PSR-F52 (or better) offers stronger value and fewer immediate limitations.
- Long-term pianist or serious student: Consider upgrading to 61-key models that include touch sensitivity or move to 88-key weighted keyboards to avoid early upgrade-need.
Conclusions
Choosing between a budget keyboard and a better build depends on your goals. The Alesis Melody 61 MK4 is a sensible gateway instrument, while the Yamaha PSR-F52 offers a stronger foundation for those who expect to commit to learning. If budget allows, starting with a higher-quality keyboard reduces the need to upgrade early and supports technique development more effectively.
Sources
- Alesis Melody 61 MK4 product listing: https://www.amazon.com/Alesis-MK4-61-Key-Keyboard-Beginners-Speakers/dp/B0D2CYH6Q7
- Alesis Melody 61 MK4 product announcement: https://rekkerd.org/alesis-launches-melody-61-mk4-beginner-friendly-keyboard/
- Alesis Melody 61 Key Review (video): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pesOEusRQUo
- Yamaha PSR-F52 Review: https://www.wanderingtunes.com/yamaha-psr-f52-review/
- Yamaha PSR-F52 product listing: https://www.thomannmusic.com/yamaha_psr_f52.htm
- Yamaha PSR-F52 Review (Buyer Guide): https://producerhive.com/buyer-guides/keys/yamaha-psr-f52-review/
- Yamaha PSR-F52 Demo Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUL5axTpQk0
Definitions & Translations
Touch sensitivity (velocity-response)
Definition: A keyboard feature where the volume or timbre of a note changes depending on how hard the key is pressed.
Origin/Note: Common English term in digital instruments, distinguishing late-entry models without this function.
Professional Acceptance: Recognised as important in music education for expressive playing and advanced technique.
Full-size keys
Definition: Keys that match the width of standard acoustic piano keys, allowing proper hand spacing and posture.
Origin/Note: Distinguishes from narrower or mini keys often found in toy keyboards.
Professional Acceptance: Important for smooth transition to larger or acoustic piano instruments.
61-key keyboard
Definition: A digital keyboard with sixty-one keys (typically five octaves plus one key).
Origin/Note: Specifies key count; common in beginner models to balance size, cost and functionality.
Professional Acceptance: Acceptable for many beginners, but some teachers prefer 88 keys for full repertoire potential.
My Diary - Leonardo Cardillo 